Wednesday, December 19, 2012

Guns

Ten Arguments Gun Advocates Make, and Why They're Wrong - American Prospect

"A guide to the debate we'll be having, or at least we ought to have."

"2. Guns don't kill people, people kill people.
But there aren't mass shootings every few weeks in England or Costa Rica or Japan, and the reason is that people in those places who have these impulses don't have an easy way to access lethal weapons and unlimited ammunition.

3. If only everybody around was armed, an ordinary civilian could take out a mass killer before he got too far.
The truth is that in a chaotic situation, even highly trained police officers often kill bystanders. The idea that some accountant who spent a few hours at the range would suddenly turn into Jason Bourne and take out the killer without doing more harm than good has no basis in reality.

6. The Constitution says I have a right to own guns.
Yes it does, but for some reason gun advocates think that the right to bear arms is the only constitutional right that is virtually without limit. You have the right to practice your religion, but not if your religion involves human sacrifice. You have the right to free speech, but you can still be prosecuted for incitement or conspiracy, and you can be sued for libel. Every right is subject to limitation when it begins to threaten others, and the Supreme Court has affirmed that even though there is an individual right to gun ownership, the government can put reasonable restrictions on that right.

8. Guns are a part of American culture.
Indeed they are, but so are a lot of things, and that tells us nothing about whether they're good or bad and how we want to treat them going forward. Slavery was a part of American culture for a couple of hundred years, but eventually we decided it had to go."

I say, keep your guns, ban the ammunition.

http://globalsociology.com/2012/12/15/on-the-guns-thing-i-would-just-like-to-point-out/



No comments: